{
  "snapshot_id": "beea0cac8dee68bc4a771a5a756624fb2b52620d9cf2ac400791d1e962b4a953",
  "planned_trials": 24,
  "comparable_trials": 23,
  "must_disagreements": 9,
  "pass_flips": 8,
  "score_disagreements": 17,
  "position_strata": {
    "same": {
      "trials": 6,
      "must_disagreements": 2
    },
    "different": {
      "trials": 17,
      "must_disagreements": 7
    }
  },
  "items": [
    {
      "trial_id": "7a40c69a1a02753f0f2d",
      "task_id": "hands",
      "prompt": "A realistic close-up photograph of two adult hands holding a plain white ceramic cup. Both hands are fully visible. Neutral background, natural daylight, no text.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 2,
          "condition": "One plain white cup",
          "R": true,
          "M": false
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "519c0a4fced75682e79805a12b5b565d8e9fa2d7ffb4037e0f133f82766ba829",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/7a40c69a1a02753f0f2d.webp",
      "published_sha256": "a0809e187fa5db21d14be34c62574a33e350f883d84d022b66b4a995f463af31",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 3",
        "reason": "Two adult hands hold one plain white cup. Both hands are visible and finger structure appears normal without obvious duplication or fusion. The image is realistic and close-up with natural light, though the background includes a tabletop/interior rather than a neutral plain backdrop.",
        "passed": true
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 3",
        "reason": "Exactly two adult hands are visible and both appear anatomically coherent without duplicated or fused fingers. However, the cup contains a dark beverage, so it is not a plain white cup as requested. The setting has natural daylight and a realistic close-up composition.",
        "passed": false
      }
    },
    {
      "trial_id": "587e57b2e1e0afe9e617",
      "task_id": "product",
      "prompt": "Studio product photograph of one matte black cylindrical water bottle with a silver cap, centered on a light gray seamless background. No text or branding. Soft shadow to the right.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 0,
          "condition": "One black cylindrical bottle with silver cap",
          "R": true,
          "M": false
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "108661fea478d82f5dbfb776a054db511bcbdbe794aee9b15c27708b58323038",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/587e57b2e1e0afe9e617.webp",
      "published_sha256": "aad6c21354e957002fe1bff6892cb08e0396b0b14720620d0a55b4c044da7534",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 1",
        "reason": "Shows a single matte black bottle centered on a light gray seamless background with a silver cap and no visible text or branding. A soft shadow extends to the right. Bottle body is slightly less purely cylindrical due to more pronounced shoulder curvature, but overall matches well.",
        "passed": true
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 3",
        "reason": "Single black bottle on a light gray seamless background with no visible text or branding, and the shadow falls to the right. However, the cap includes a metal loop/handle structure, so it is not just a simple silver cap as requested.",
        "passed": false
      }
    },
    {
      "trial_id": "5cb4438ef352cbe1d149",
      "task_id": "room",
      "prompt": "Interior photograph of a small reading room. A green armchair stands to the left of a tall window. A wooden bookshelf stands to the right of the window. One floor lamp behind the armchair. No people.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 2,
          "condition": "One floor lamp behind the chair",
          "R": true,
          "M": false
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "acd7b1e6480e1fc4893179ecdd6150feabc7e44fd4700d73b564b7f1fa7af1b4",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/5cb4438ef352cbe1d149.webp",
      "published_sha256": "7413657ec4dad595f08a950cd17b25892b5e8073f02663b7494a1e3963548c9f",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 1",
        "reason": "Green armchair is positioned left of the central tall window, wooden bookshelf is on the right side of the window, one floor lamp stands behind the armchair, and no people are visible.",
        "passed": true
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 3",
        "reason": "Green armchair is left of the window and bookshelf is right of the window, with no people visible. However, the floor lamp is beside/left of the chair rather than clearly behind it.",
        "passed": false
      }
    },
    {
      "trial_id": "ef9402d0c5a9491d49a3",
      "task_id": "room",
      "prompt": "Interior photograph of a small reading room. A green armchair stands to the left of a tall window. A wooden bookshelf stands to the right of the window. One floor lamp behind the armchair. No people.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 2,
          "condition": "One floor lamp behind the chair",
          "R": true,
          "M": false
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "90950389816b674e16cc8d92a3ec21e56184eda14b1cdf21ae7fbf4086e67b58",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/ef9402d0c5a9491d49a3.webp",
      "published_sha256": "6e67eeb67f98bc2544053f2ba387826848fc939a3d586f7c2b89622a68f02e18",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 3",
        "reason": "Green armchair is left of the window, the bookshelf is to the right of the window, and one floor lamp stands behind the chair on the left. No people are visible. The scene remains a small reading room interior.",
        "passed": true
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 1",
        "reason": "Green armchair is positioned left of the tall window, and a wooden bookshelf is to the right of the window. No people are visible. The lamp is to the left of the chair rather than clearly behind it.",
        "passed": false
      }
    },
    {
      "trial_id": "40186cebbdc4609a29db",
      "task_id": "building",
      "prompt": "Architectural photograph of a single-story white house with a flat roof, exactly two square front windows and one central wooden front door. Eye-level frontal view, overcast daylight, no people or cars.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 1,
          "condition": "Exactly two square front windows",
          "R": true,
          "M": false
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "d5a91cf97de432e57aaa6e5ec3a06c2a28fb0a5891fa9126b17e2580fafb8038",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/40186cebbdc4609a29db.webp",
      "published_sha256": "7de74185a3a18bc36c7cedccbc1afcaddf89c4ce7378cff74424cb4d5f2d5e86",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 3",
        "reason": "Single-story white house with flat roof, exactly two square front windows, and one central wooden front door. Eye-level frontal view with overcast daylight; no people or cars visible.",
        "passed": true
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 2",
        "reason": "Single-story white house with flat roof, central wooden door, frontal eye-level composition, and no people or cars. However, each of the two front windows is tall rectangular, not square.",
        "passed": false
      }
    },
    {
      "trial_id": "bb43d41599c01c460209",
      "task_id": "building",
      "prompt": "Architectural photograph of a single-story white house with a flat roof, exactly two square front windows and one central wooden front door. Eye-level frontal view, overcast daylight, no people or cars.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 1,
          "condition": "Exactly two square front windows",
          "R": true,
          "M": false
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "1f65fc44b4600f5e4c2250557b5b6eda4a71ddbeb9d225397feface0a696268b",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/bb43d41599c01c460209.webp",
      "published_sha256": "43e7f61d8f7cbbf929b3bbc9828818bceae76e4568f4a964c1c78d5268ad9617",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 1",
        "reason": "Single-story white house with a flat roof, eye-level frontal composition. Two square front windows are visible, one on each side of a central wooden front door. No people or cars are present.",
        "passed": true
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 1",
        "reason": "Single-story white house with a flat roof in a frontal eye-level view under overcast sky. There are two front windows, but they are rectangular rather than clearly square. One central wooden door is present. No people or cars are visible.",
        "passed": false
      }
    },
    {
      "trial_id": "5435b72e475a272c1f27",
      "task_id": "count",
      "prompt": "Top-down photograph of a white plate with exactly five strawberries arranged in a ring. The plate is centered on a blue tablecloth. No utensils and no other food.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 1,
          "condition": "Strawberries arranged in a ring on a white plate",
          "R": false,
          "M": true
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "4c62594465e428d9ccd22d330b588c240e481cbf4c2db2d83c9512eba4081058",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/5435b72e475a272c1f27.webp",
      "published_sha256": "1e0327e983393e4657decb92d7a79a69c15cb847b95750faad5b1c0c0f170d2e",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 3",
        "reason": "There are only four strawberries visible, not five. They form an approximate ring on a white plate, and the background is a blue tablecloth with no utensils or other food.",
        "passed": false
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 1",
        "reason": "There are only four strawberries visible, placed in a circular/ring-like arrangement on a white plate centered on a blue tablecloth. No utensils or other food are present.",
        "passed": false
      }
    },
    {
      "trial_id": "75623097719d724810dd",
      "task_id": "count",
      "prompt": "Top-down photograph of a white plate with exactly five strawberries arranged in a ring. The plate is centered on a blue tablecloth. No utensils and no other food.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 0,
          "condition": "Exactly five strawberries",
          "R": false,
          "M": true
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "7ddf26fbdbaeddd4ed763a3b34ffd5b094a813af5fb67d62053aca6edb829220",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/75623097719d724810dd.webp",
      "published_sha256": "81a279b8d40232c39e2b729953c74fa78e889613b77041c97da4a3f990a12094",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 1",
        "reason": "There are only four strawberries visible, arranged roughly in a ring on a white plate. The plate is centered on a blue tablecloth, and there are no utensils or other food.",
        "passed": false
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 3",
        "reason": "Top-down view shows a centered white plate on a blue tablecloth with exactly five strawberries arranged in a ring. No utensils or other food are visible.",
        "passed": true
      }
    },
    {
      "trial_id": "8e029ba70f063d5b528d",
      "task_id": "material",
      "prompt": "A square macro photograph of a folded linen napkin beside one wooden spoon on a pale stone countertop. Clearly visible linen weave, wood grain, and stone texture. Warm side lighting, no text.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "index": 0,
          "condition": "One folded linen napkin and one wooden spoon",
          "R": true,
          "M": false
        }
      ],
      "original_sha256": "7d2e4747e1e36732d156763e97f24ec9319eb6c7d37828149b439b89ae914894",
      "published_image": "/notes/media-audit-images/8e029ba70f063d5b528d.webp",
      "published_sha256": "8d562548a50ba7b2a0fd234db5e0d91bce892d35024fbf7e2582eded94e6c71e",
      "R": {
        "label": "Candidate 1",
        "reason": "Shows one folded linen napkin and one wooden spoon on a pale stone countertop. Linen weave, wood grain, and porous stone texture are all clearly visible. No text is present. Warm side lighting is evident from the left, though an extra bowl appears in frame.",
        "passed": true
      },
      "M": {
        "label": "Candidate 2",
        "reason": "Contains one folded linen napkin and one wooden spoon, but also includes an additional bowl in the top right, so it does not satisfy the requirement of one napkin and one spoon only. Linen weave, wood grain, and stone texture are visible. No text present.",
        "passed": false
      }
    }
  ]
}